About Regan Roth Insurance Agency

Regan Insurance Agency was founded in 1954 by Carlton Regan. In 1958, the original office was constructed on Plantation Key as the business outgrew Carlton's residence on Lower Matecumbe. Additions were made to the building and to the staff with Robert E. Regan (Bob) joining his father Carlton in 1972. Together, with his wife Charlen, Bob worked with Carlton to grow the family run agency and in 1995 the building was once again renovated and expanded as the third generation became actively involved in the operation of the agency. Robert Regan II, Catherine Regan, Lorie Head and Joseph (Joe) H. Roth III, CIC took on the roles of active management, ownership, and production along with a talented staff of seasoned insurance professionals.  In April of 2019, Joe Roth III partnering with lifelong friend Robert C. Stoky, assumed the role as managing owner of the agency and rebranded the company as “Regan Roth Insurance” recognizing the contributions of those who came before, the Regan family legacy, and the future direction of the company.  In May of 2023, Sara M. Roth, CIC joined the agency with a degree in Risk Management Insurance and a master’s degree in risk management insurance from Florida State University.  Sara is the fourth generation of “Regan-Roths” working in the agency.  Jennifer Miller Roth has also joined the agency after obtaining her 2-20 general lines license in 2020 and currently assists with day-to-day operations. Regan Roth continues to have an excellent team of recent recruits and seasoned professionals. Commitment to community and the promise to provide quality insurance products, knowledge, and service remain the focus today.